Every fly angler faces the same fundamental challenge: how to comfortably and efficiently carry essential gear—fly boxes, tippet, leaders, tools, water, maybe even a camera—while keeping hands free for casting and managing line. Two dominant solutions have emerged: the chest pack and the hip pack (often called a lumbar pack). But which one is truly better?
The answer, as with most things in fly fishing, is: it depends. Your fishing style, the type of water you frequent, the amount of gear you carry, and personal comfort preferences all play a significant role.
This article dives deep into the chest pack vs. hip pack debate, comparing their strengths and weaknesses, and showcasing some top-tier options like the rugged Thunderhead series and versatile Orvis packs available right here, to help you make the best choice for your adventures on the water.
What is a Fly Fishing Chest Pack?
A chest pack sits high on your torso, secured by shoulder straps and often a waist strap. It keeps your gear readily accessible right in front of you.
General Pros:
- Accessibility: Gear is front-and-center, making it incredibly easy to grab flies, tippet, or tools without much movement.
- Deep Wading: Keeps gear completely out of the water, even when wading waist-deep or higher.
- Weight Distribution: Spreads weight across the shoulders and upper back, which some find more comfortable for heavier loads over long periods.
- Backpack Integration: Many chest packs can integrate with larger backpacks for backcountry trips or carrying extra layers.
General Cons:
- Casting Interference: Can sometimes feel bulky in front, potentially interfering with casting motion or line management for some anglers.
- Visibility: Can obstruct the view directly downwards when navigating tricky terrain or watching your footing.
- Warmth: Can feel warmer in hot weather due to coverage on the chest.
Introducing: The Thunderhead Chest Pack
If high-and-dry accessibility is your priority, the Thunderhead Chest Pack is a prime example of a purpose-built, element-proof solution.
- Built Tough & Waterproof: Crafted from ultra-durable 900D TPU Coated NewStream Fabric with a fully waterproof, self-healing TRU Zip zipper on the main compartment, it’s designed to protect your essentials from downpours or accidental dips.
- Smart Storage: Offers 5L (305 Cu. In.) of space (Interior: 9” x 7” x 3.75”) with internal organization and a front stretch pocket. Critically, it features an integrated net slot in the lightweight foam back panel, perfect for long or short-handled nets.
- Versatility: It's not just a standalone pack (1.05 lbs). Modular buckles allow it to detach from its harness (Back Harness: 11” x 9”) and integrate seamlessly with compatible backpacks or be lashed to a boat frame for quick, secure storage during wet rides. Exterior Hypalon® tabs provide ample attachment points for tools.
What is a Fly Fishing Hip Pack (Lumbar Pack)?
A hip pack, or lumbar pack, sits on your lower back or hip area, secured by a waist belt, often with an optional shoulder strap for added support, especially with heavier loads.
General Pros:
- Unobstructed Casting: Keeps your chest and arms completely free for unrestricted casting and line management.
- Clear View: Doesn't impede your downward vision, making wading and hiking easier.
- Cooler: Less body coverage makes it more comfortable in warmer climates.
- Versatility: Can often be swung around to the front for access without removing it.
General Cons:
- Deep Wading Limitation: Gear can get submerged during very deep wading unless the pack is fully waterproof and sealed.
- Accessibility: Requires reaching back or swinging the pack forward to access gear.
- Weight Distribution: Concentrates weight on the hips and lower back, which might be less comfortable for some with very heavy loads without a shoulder strap.
Hip Pack Showcase: Thunderhead & Orvis Options
Hip packs offer fantastic freedom, and modern designs provide incredible features, especially regarding waterproofness and organization.
1. Thunderhead Small Submersible Lumbar:
- Compact & Waterproof: Ideal for anglers who want minimalist carry but maximum protection. Features the same tough 900D TPU NewStream Fabric and fully submersible TRU Zip as its larger siblings. Offers 4.5L (275 Cu. In.) capacity (10.5” x 7.5” x 3.5”).
- Modular Master: A key feature is its compatibility with Switchback Wading Systems and the South Fork belt – the hip belt is removable, allowing direct integration.
- Feature Rich: Includes an integrated net slot, removable zippered pouch inside, water-resistant front pocket, comfortable foam back panel, adjustable shoulder strap, and tool attachment points. Weighs 1.3lbs.
2. Thunderhead Submersible Lumbar:
- The All-Rounder: This is the larger, fully waterproof workhorse (10L / 610 Cu. In. capacity - 13.5” x 9” x 5”) built for bigger adventures or carrying more gear, including cameras.
- Ultimate Protection: Boasts the 900D TPU NewStream Fabric and the airtight TRU Zip closure.
- Comfort & Organization: Features excellent padding on the back panel and hip belt, an adjustable padded shoulder strap, interior organization with a removable pocket, integrated net slot, and multiple exterior attachment points. Weighs 1.9lbs.
- Efficiency Focused: Designed for anglers prioritizing organization and quick access in a non-submersible format. Known for its intelligently placed compartments.
- Comfort & Durability: Features an ergonomic design and durable, water-resistant (not fully waterproof) fabric to protect gear from splashes and light rain. Keeps weight comfortably on the hips.
4. Orvis Pro Waterproof Hip Pack 10L:
- Serious Waterproofing: For anglers demanding complete submersible protection. Features a TPU-coated nylon exterior and a top-tier TIZIP® MasterSeal zipper.
- Ample Space & Comfort: Offers 10L of secure, dry storage with an ergonomic waist belt and adjustable shoulder strap for comfortable all-day wear, even when loaded.
Head-to-Head: Chest Pack vs Hip Pack Decision Factors
| Feature | Chest Pack (e.g., Thunderhead Chest Pack) | Hip Pack (e.g., Thunderhead Lumbar, Orvis Packs) | Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Excellent: Gear is right in front. | Good: Requires reaching back or swinging pack forward. | How often do you change flies or need tools? |
| Deep Wading | Excellent: Gear stays high and dry. | Variable: Good if waterproof/submersible (Thunderhead/Orvis Pro), limited otherwise. | How deep do you typically wade? |
| Casting Freedom | Good: Can feel slightly bulky for some. | Excellent: Completely unobstructed torso and arms. | Does anything on your chest interfere with your cast? |
| Comfort/Weight | Distributes weight on shoulders/back. Can feel warm. | Concentrates weight on hips/lumbar. Cooler wear. | How much gear do you carry? What feels best on your body? |
| Capacity | Moderate (e.g., Thunderhead 5L) | Variable (e.g., Thunderhead Small 4.5L, Thunderhead/Orvis Pro 10L) | How much gear do you need for a typical day? |
| Waterproofness | Excellent options available (Thunderhead). | Excellent options available (Thunderhead, Orvis Pro). | Do you fish in heavy rain or risk falling in? Is submersible protection vital? |
| Versatility | Often integrates with backpacks, boat lashing (Thunderhead). | Can integrate with wading belts (Thunderhead Small), often includes shoulder straps. | Do you need backpack integration or belt modularity? |
| Visibility (Downward) | Can obstruct view directly below. | Unobstructed view. | How important is seeing your feet while wading tricky sections? |
| Net Carrying | Often integrated back panel slot (Thunderhead). | Often integrated slot or loops (Thunderhead, Orvis). | How do you prefer to carry your net? |
So, Which is Better For You?
- Choose a CHEST PACK if:
- You frequently wade deep and need gear clear of the water.
- You prioritize instant, front-and-center access to your gear.
- You plan to integrate your pack with a larger backpack.
- You don't mind potential minor casting interference or blocked downward view.
- The Thunderhead Chest Pack is an outstanding waterproof and versatile choice.
- Choose a HIP PACK if:
- Maximum casting freedom and an unobstructed front are your top priorities.
- You primarily wade in shallower water or want submersible protection for moderate depths (choose waterproof models like Thunderhead or Orvis Pro).
- You prefer weight carried on your hips/lumbar region.
- You want a cooler option for warm weather.
- You need varying capacities, from minimalist (Thunderhead Small Lumbar) to guide-level (Thunderhead Lumbar, Orvis Pro 10L), or highly organized (Orvis Guide).
The Final Cast
There's no single "best" pack—only the best pack for your needs. Both chest packs and hip packs offer excellent ways to carry your fly fishing essentials. By considering how and where you fish, and prioritizing features like accessibility, waterproofness, comfort, and capacity, you can find the perfect solution.
Explore our collection of Fishpond packs and Orvis packs today. Investing in a high-quality, well-designed pack like those featured here enhances your comfort, organization, and overall enjoyment on the water. Spend less time fumbling for gear and more time focused on the fish.
FAQ
- Q: What's the main difference between a fly fishing chest pack and hip pack?
A: A chest pack sits high on your torso, offering easy front access and keeping gear dry in deep water. A hip pack (or lumbar pack) rests on your lower back/hips, providing maximum casting freedom and keeping your front clear. - Q: When should I choose a fly fishing chest pack?
A: Choose a chest pack if you frequently wade deep, prioritize immediate front access to gear, want backpack integration options (like the Thunderhead Chest Pack), and don't mind potential minor casting interference. - Q: Why choose a fly fishing hip pack over a chest pack?
A: Opt for a hip pack for unrestricted casting motion, a clear downward view for wading, and cooler wear in warm weather. Many modern hip packs (like the Thunderhead series or Orvis Pro) also offer excellent waterproof protection. - Q: Are chest packs or hip packs better for deep wading?
A: Chest packs are generally better for deep wading because they position gear higher on your body, keeping it consistently out of the water. While waterproof hip packs exist, chest packs offer more inherent clearance. - Q: Do chest packs interfere with fly casting?
A: For some anglers, chest packs can feel slightly bulky in front and potentially interfere with their casting stroke or line management. Hip packs completely avoid this by keeping the chest and arms unobstructed.